Back

Is SEO Worth It?

Is SEO Worth It? This is a question that is asked a lot by prospective clients, by business owners at networking events, and increasingly by people who’ve read that AI is making search engines irrelevant. So let me give you the TL;DR first:

Yes, SEO is worth it for majority of businesses. But not all businesses, not in all situations, and especially not if it’s done badly. That nuance matters. In classic SEO fashion, “it depends”.

Does SEO Actually Work?

Let’s start with a basic overview. Organic search still accounts for the majority of website traffic across the majority of industries.

But what about ChatGPT? Isn’t everyone using AI instead of Google now? – Completely valid and this is something that is getting asked more and more. You should be aware that this is a new channel for exposure and visibility.

The data though, shows a slightly different story. Similarweb published audience overlap data in March 2026. As of February 2026, which shows around 14% of Google’s visitors also used ChatGPT. That means roughly 86% of people using Google aren’t using ChatGPT to aid in their search. This trend is growing though, it was around 5% in mid 2023 and has climbed steadily since. People are using tools like ChatGPT alongside Google, not instead of it.

The audience overlap data is particularly interesting. Google’s traffic volume still dwarfs ChatGPT’s by a large margin. Even the 14% who use both aren’t abandoning Google – they’re adding another tool to how they search. Google is still processing billions of queries every single day, and that isn’t changing anytime soon.

What’s more relevant for a business owner though is the quality of that traffic. People who find you through search are actively looking for what you offer. They’ve typed a query into Google because they have a need and they want information, they want to compare options, or they want to buy something.

This is why organic search leads tend to convert at significantly higher rates than outbound. The intent is already there. Your job is simply to show up when the search happens.

The ROI of SEO vs Other Channels

One of the most compelling arguments for SEO is how it compares to the alternatives. In particular paid advertising.

SEO vs PPC

With PPC (Google Ads, Bing Ads etc.), you pay for every single click. The moment you stop spending, the traffic stops. There’s no residual value. You’re essentially renting visibility. SEO in contrast compounds over time. The content you create, the technical improvements you make, the authority you build, all of these continue working for you long after the initial investment. A blog post you publish today could still be driving traffic and generating leads two years from now.

That said, PPC has its place. If you need immediate visibility after launching a new product, testing market demand, or covering a gap while your SEO momentum builds, paid ads deliver instant results. The best approach for most businesses is to use both in a strategic manner, rather than treating them as an either or decision.

The key difference is in long term cost efficiency. Over a 12 month period, a well executed SEO campaign will almost always deliver a lower cost per acquisition compared to PPC, because the traffic you earn organically doesn’t have a per click cost attached to it. The investment is in the work to earn that traffic.

SEO vs Social Media

Social media is excellent for brand building, community engagement, and reaching audiences who might not be actively searching for what you offer. But organic reach on social platforms has been declining steadily for years, and the content you create has an extremely short lifespan. A LinkedIn post might get attention for 48 hours. A well optimised blog post can drive traffic for years.

Social media also requires constant content production to maintain visibility, whereas SEO allows you to build a library of assets that work for you continuously. The two complement each other well. Social can amplify your SEO content and drive initial traffic to new pages but as a standalone strategy for generating consistent leads, SEO is almost always more effective.

When SEO Is Worth the Investment

To be helpful, rather than just giving you the answer you want to hear, let me be specific about the situations where SEO is worth it.

Your customers are searching for what you offer

This sounds obvious, but it’s the fundamental test. If people are actively typing queries into Google that relate to your products or services, then ranking for those queries puts you directly in front of potential customers the moment they have intent. This applies to every service based business, most ecommerce businesses, and the majority of B2B companies.

You can commit for at least 6 to 12 months

SEO isn’t a quick win. The first three months are typically auditing, fixing issues, building foundations and laying out the strategic groundwork. Months three to six usually start showing ranking improvements. Meaningful commercial returns such as leads and revenue typically follow from months six to twelve onwards. If you’re only willing to invest for a month or two, you’ll almost certainly be disappointed, and you’ll have wasted whatever you spent. Those numbers there are a guideline, things can and have happened at a faster rate for businesses in the past.

The businesses I’ve worked with who see the strongest returns are the ones who commit to a long term strategy and treat SEO as a revenue channel rather than an experiment.

You’re in a market where organic visibility matters

Some industries are dominated by organic search as a customer acquisition channel. Legal services, healthcare, ecommerce, SaaS, financial services, trades, professional services etc. in all of these, a significant portion of new business comes from people searching online. If that describes your market, the question isn’t really whether to invest in SEO, but how much to invest.

You want to reduce dependency on paid advertising

If your current marketing strategy relies heavily on PPC, you are at the mercy of rising click costs and platform changes. Google Ad costs have increased significantly over the past few years and they’re not trending downward. SEO offers a way to build a sustainable traffic source that doesn’t require continuous spending per click.

When SEO Might Not Be Worth It

Being honest about when SEO isn’t the right investment is more useful than pretending it’s the answer to everything.

You need results immediately

If your business can’t afford to wait 3 to 6 months for traction, SEO alone isn’t going to solve your problem. You’d be better served by PPC or direct outreach in the short term, with SEO as a parallel investment that pays off over the medium to long term. Using SEO as an emergency revenue lever is setting yourself up for disappointment.

You’re not prepared to invest properly

Meaningful SEO for most businesses requires real investment. If your budget is £200 per month and you’re a nationally focused business, you’re not going to get enough work done to move the needle, and whatever you spend will feel wasted. You’d be better off investing in a one off audit to understand your position, then implementing the simpler recommendations yourself until your budget allows for proper investment.

You’re expecting guaranteed results

If an SEO provider has promised you “number one on Google” or “page one within 30 days”, they’ve set expectations very high. This also depends on the terms they’re stating can get you to position 1 quickly – are these branded terms, or low volume, low competition terms? Rankings depend on competition, algorithm changes, and lots of other variables. Good SEO dramatically improves your chances, but it can’t guarantee specific outcomes. If you can only justify the investment on the basis of guaranteed results, you’re likely to end up frustrated. Not because SEO doesn’t work, but because the guarantee was never realistic in the first place.

Is SEO Dead? What About AI?

This question is one that never itself seems to die. SEO has died every year for as long as I can remember. Google’s AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Perplexity – the concern is that these AI tools are going to replace traditional search and make SEO irrelevant.

Here’s my take on this. AI is changing how some searches are answered, but it’s not replacing search. Google still processes billions of queries every day. The fundamentals of SEO, that of creating useful content, building a technically sound website, earning authority through quality links are exactly the same signals that AI systems use to determine which sources to cite and reference.

In fact, the overlap between what makes a page rank well in Google and what makes it likely to be cited by AI tools is significant. Clear, well structured content, strong topical authority, properly implemented structured data, E-E-A-T signals, being cited or linked to from authoritative websites. If you’re doing SEO properly, you’re simultaneously positioning your business for AI search.

The businesses that should be worried aren’t the ones investing in quality SEO. They’re the ones who were relying on thin, generic content that only ranked because of keyword targeting rather than genuine value. AI is accelerating Google’s move toward rewarding helpful content which, frankly, is exactly the direction SEO has been heading for years.

So no, SEO isn’t dead. It’s evolving, as it always has. The core principles remain the same.

How to Measure Whether Your SEO Is Working

If you’re already investing in SEO, or you’re about to start, knowing how to measure the return on investment is crucial. Too many businesses track vanity metrics that look good in reports but don’t actually tell you whether the investment is paying off.

The metrics that matter

  • Organic traffic. The most straightforward measure. Is the number of visitors coming to your site from organic search growing over time? You can track this in Google Analytics under the Acquisition reports. Look at the trend line over 6 to 12 months rather than fixating on weekly fluctuations.
  • Keyword rankings. Are you ranking for the keywords that actually matter to your business? Not just any keywords, the commercial keywords that drive enquiries and sales.
  • Conversions from organic traffic. This is the metric that really counts. Are the visitors coming from organic search actually doing something valuable? Submitting enquiry forms, making purchases, calling your business? This is where conversion tracking really matters. Commercial outcomes are the most valuable metric for measuring organic search success.
  • Cost per acquisition. Once you know how many conversions your organic traffic is generating, you can calculate how much each conversion costs by dividing your monthly SEO investment by the number of organic conversions. Compare this to your cost per conversion from paid channels. In my experience, SEO almost always wins over a 12 month period.

The metrics that don’t matter (as much as you think)

  • Domain authority or domain rating. These are useful indicators of your site’s strength, but they’re third party metrics created by SEO tool companies, not by Google. They don’t directly determine rankings. Don’t let anyone tell you that increasing your DA from 20 to 25 was the main achievement of the month unless it was accompanied by actual traffic and conversion growth. The truth is, these can also be manipulated.
  • Raw traffic numbers without context. 10,000 visitors a month means nothing if none of them are relevant to your business. I’d rather see a client get 500 highly targeted visitors who convert than 5,000 visitors from irrelevant keywords who bounce immediately.
  • Number of keywords ranked. Ranking for 200 keywords sounds impressive, but not if 190 of them are irrelevant or generate zero traffic. Focus on ranking for the keywords that drive revenue, not ones that simply exist to inflate the total count.

Is SEO Worth It for Small Businesses?

This deserves its own section because it’s one of the most common variations of the question, and the answer is slightly different than for larger businesses.

For most small businesses and especially local service businesses, SEO is one of the highest ROI marketing channels available. The competition is often less intense at the local level than at the national level, which means smaller budgets can deliver proportionally bigger results.

If you’re a plumber in Nottingham, a dental practice in Leicester, or a solicitor in Derby, the people searching for your services online are exactly your target customers. They’re local, they have intent, and they’re ready to enquire or purchase. They have a need that needs fulfilling. Ranking in the local pack for your core service keywords can fundamentally change how many enquiries you receive.

The challenge for small businesses is usually budget. SEO isn’t free and it requires either your time (if you’re doing it yourself) or your money (if you’re hiring someone). But the compounding nature of SEO means that even modest investments, applied consistently over time, can deliver meaningful results.

My recommendation for small businesses with limited budgets is to start with the fundamentals – claim and optimise your Google Business Profile, make sure your website’s basic on page SEO is in order, and focus on getting reviews from happy customers. These three things alone can significantly improve your local visibility without requiring a large ongoing investment.

If and when your budget allows, investing in a proper SEO audit and then a modest retainer can accelerate results considerably. The key is being realistic about timelines and committing to the process rather than expecting results in 30 days.

The Bottom Line

Is SEO worth it? For the vast majority of businesses, yes, it is and the data consistently backs this up. Organic search remains the largest single source of website traffic, organic leads convert at higher rates than most other channels, and the compounding nature of SEO means the return on investment tends to improve over time rather than diminish.

But worth it doesn’t mean guaranteed, and it doesn’t mean instant. It means that if you invest properly, commit for a realistic timeframe, and work with someone who knows what they’re doing, SEO is one of the most effective ways to build sustainable, long term visibility and revenue.

If you’re not sure whether SEO makes sense for your specific situation, I’m happy to have a conversation about it. Sometimes the honest answer is “not yet” or “here’s what you should do first.” I’d rather give you that advice than sell you something you don’t need. Get in touch and let’s discuss.

Lewis
Lewis
https://www.lewisadcock.co.uk/
Lewis Adcock is a freelance SEO consultant based in Derby, UK. With over 15 years of experience across agency, in-house and freelance roles, he specialises in ecommerce and Shopify SEO. He previously worked agency side and in-house as SEO Specialist. He writes about SEO from a practitioner's perspective, based on what he's seen work across real client engagements.